Seed and Plant Certification and Registration Institute (SPCRI), Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO)
Abstract: (30 Views)
Background: Bulb onion (Allium cepa L.) is widely cultivated across the world as a vegetable crop and for use in various processed food products. Despite its considerable global demand and economic importance, available knowledge regarding its phenotypic diversity remains scarce. It represents the world’s second highest‑value vegetable crop, with only tomato generating greater economic returns. Understanding phenotypic variation is essential for designing effective onion breeding strategies. The examined cultivars in this research are: "PX07713119", "Calista", "Dolunay", "Surin", "Red Moon", "MT 120", "Belmar", "Red Amposta", "Tucannon", "White Valencia", "Hitit", and "Kilgarsalan". This study aimed to identify superior cultivars through the evaluation of quantitative characteristics.
Materials and Methods: The experiment was carried out at the Seed and Plant Certification and Registration Institute (SPCRI), Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO) in Karaj, Iran, during the spring and summer seasons of 2023 and 2024, employing a randomized complete block design with two replications. The evaluation of the cultivars was conducted using a total of eight morphological traits: (i) leaf-related traits: the number of leaves per pseudo-stem, leaf length, leaf diameter, (ii) pseudo-stem-related traits: pseudo-stem length, pseudo-stem diameter; and (iii) bulb-related traits: bulb height, bulb diameter, and bulb neck thickness. The selected traits were based on their frequent observation in previous onion characterization studies and their straightforward measurement in field conditions, adhering to widely recognized descriptors for assessing diversity within Allium species. In the same plants, the number of leaves was recorded, and measurements of leaf length and width were performed using standard measuring tools. To mitigate diurnal variation, especially in leaf and pseudo-stem diameter, these measurements were taken during morning hours. Principal component analysis (PCA) was employed on the quantitative traits to identify the most significant characteristics. The quantitative data were subsequently utilized to compute a standardized Euclidean distance matrix and to create a dendrogram. A specialized TOPSIS (Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution) algorithm, specifically the Mahalanobis TOPSIS variant, was developed to formulate an all-encompassing multi-criteria decision-making framework. Employing this established model, the breeding value of twelve distinct hybrid long-day onion cultivars was evaluated and subsequently ranked.
Results: The Combined Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) over the two years revealed significant differences in quantitative traits among cultivars (p >0.05). The number of leaves per pseudo-stem ranged from 6.81 (Calista) to 10.40 (Red Moon). Leaf length was maximum (49.80 cm) for cultivar Red Moon and minimum (34.96 cm) for White Valencia. Bulb height was maximum noted in MT 120 (8.99 cm) whereas, White Valencia showed a minimum (6.65 cm). Bulb diameter ranged from 6.81 cm (Hitit) to 9.01 cm (Red Amposta). Whereas, leaf diameter was maximum recorded in MT120 (2.07 cm) and minimum in White Valencia (1.09 cm). Pseudo-stem length ranged from 7.82 cm (PX07713119) to 23.93 cm (Red Moon) whereas pseudo-stem diameter ranged from 1.68 cm (PX07713119) to 7.41 cm (Red moon). The minimum neck thickness (4.79 mm) was recorded in PX07713119 while the maximum (15.59 mm) in Red Moon. The Pearson correlation analysis was performed to determine the correlations between various quantitative traits. Correlation analysis showed positive associations such as leaf diameter with leaf length (r= 0.88), Pseudo-stem length with pseudo-stem diameter (r= 0.69), Bulb height with Bulb diameter (r= 0.77), leaf length with Bulb height and Bulb diameter (r= 0.68; r= 0.69), and leaf diameter with Bulb height and Bulb diameter (r= 0.76; r= 0.81), suggesting joint adjustment of these quantitative traits in the twelve investigated onion cultivars. Multivariate analysis (including PCA, M-TOPSIS, and clustering) revealed considerable phenotypic difference among long-day onion cultivars. The eigenvalues associated with the main components reflect their relevance to specific traits. The PCA results showed that the first three main components, which had eigenvalues greater than one, collectively accounted more than 92.07% of the overall variability measured in 12 cultivars for quantitative characteristics. The first two components accounted for 76.47% variability. PCA revealed that PC1 (50.29%) represented leaf (length and diameter), PC2 (26.18%) reflected pseudo-stem (length and diameter), and PC3 (15.59%) was associated with morphological traits related to bulb height and number of leaves per pseudo-stem. Cultivars Red Moon, MT 120, and Surin exhibited superior morphological features with high M-TOPSIS value, while MT 120, Red Amposta, and Belmar were the top three cultivars evaluated using the M-TOPSIS approach based on two economical measured traits (bulb height and bulb diameter), respectively. Ward clustering based on square Euclidean distances for the quantitative markers grouped the cultivars into four major clusters, indicating the high diversity level present among the cultivars. This analysis revealed three multi- and one mono-genotypic clusters of the cultivars. Cluster I had five cultivars. This cluster was further divided into two sub clusters i.e. Group IA and Group IB. Group IA consists of Red Amposta and Calista. Group IB comprised of Belmar, Dolunay and Tucannon. Cluster II had one cultivar (PX07713119) and cluster III had three cultivars (Hitit, Kilgarsalan, and White Valencia). Cultivars like MT120, Red moon and Surin were grouped in cluster IV.
Conclusions: This assessment revealed pronounced variations in morphological traits across the cultivars, consequently influencing critical aspects of breeding programs and the creation of value-added products. The application of multivariate statistical methods facilitated precise discrimination between cultivars according to their structural features, thereby establishing a foundation for targeted breeding methodologies. These findings are highly valuable as a reference for identifying cultivars that exhibit suitable quantitative characteristics.
Type of Study:
Research |
Subject:
ساير Received: 2026/04/17 | Accepted: 2026/07/15